← All writing

Consciousness

The Illusion of the Permanent Self

We talk about ourselves as if we were fixed. Memory, relationships, and experience keep quietly proving otherwise.

We say things like "I am just not a morning person," or "That is not who I am," as if there were a fixed self underneath everything, sealed and stable.

Look closely and that fixed self is hard to find.

Memory rebuilds us

Memory feels like a recording. It is not. Research on memory suggests we reconstruct memories each time we recall them, and they can shift in the process. The story of who you are is being edited all the time, mostly without your knowledge.

I wrote a whole book, The Road to Ronda, under a strict rule that nothing could be invented. Where I could check something, I checked it. Doing that taught me how much work it takes to keep memory honest.

Relationships shape us

You are not the same person with everyone. You are a slightly different self with your parents, your children, your oldest friend, and your boss. That is not fakeness. It is how people work. Selves form in relationship.

Which means when relationships change, end, or begin, we change with them.

Experience remakes us

Big experiences can reorganize a person. Loss. Love. Illness. A moment of insight. I have been through a year that removed nearly everything I had built my identity on, and the person who came out the other side holds different beliefs, wants different things, and loves differently.

I would not say he is a different person. I also would not say he is the same one.

Awareness as the constant

If almost everything about the self changes, what stays? For me, the answer that keeps coming back is awareness itself. The noticing. The part that was present for all of the versions.

That is an interpretation, not a fact, and thoughtful people disagree about it.

Why this is good news

If the self were fixed, change would be impossible. You would be stuck with whoever you were at twenty. The fact that the self is fluid means growth is not a fantasy. It is the normal condition of being a person.

The next time you hear yourself say "that is just who I am," it might be worth asking: is it, or is it just who I have been?

identityselfimpermanencechange
Jaime Boyaca

Technology executive, speaker and explorer of consciousness. This idea is also the heart of his keynote From Reaction to Response.