Consciousness
What Does It Mean to Be Conscious?
Science can describe a great deal about the brain. It still cannot tell us why there is anyone home to experience it.
In 2003, in an apartment in the East Village, a roommate handed me something and told me nothing about it. He wanted to compare experiences, and he did not want my expectations getting in the way.
It was DMT. I did not know that at the time.
What I remember is a vast white room. I thought I had died. And in that room, with no body I could find and nothing I recognized, one thought arrived with complete clarity.
I still am.
Not I still have a body. Not I still have my name, or my memories, or my life. Just that something was still here, aware, experiencing. Everything else had been taken away and that was what was left.
I came back no longer afraid of death. I have spent a lot of the years since trying to understand what that experience was pointing at.
The question nobody has answered
Here is what we know. The brain is extraordinarily complex. Specific regions are associated with specific experiences. Damage one area and you lose language. Stimulate another and someone reports seeing a face. Anesthesia can switch experience off and on again. Neuroscience has made remarkable progress mapping which physical processes go along with which experiences.
Here is what we do not know. Why any of it feels like something.
A thermostat responds to temperature. As far as we can tell, it does not experience warmth. Your brain responds to temperature too, and somehow there is also the feeling of being warm. Philosophers call this the hard problem of consciousness, and it is called hard because nobody has solved it. Not neuroscientists, not philosophers, not anyone.
Awareness and what we are aware of
One distinction has helped me more than any other. There is the content of experience, and there is the awareness that experiences it.
The content is everything that changes. Thoughts, feelings, sounds, sensations, memories, the story you tell about who you are. It moves constantly.
The awareness is the part that notices. It seems not to move. It was there when you were a child and it is there now, even though almost every piece of content has changed.
In that white room, the content was stripped almost to nothing. What remained was the awareness. I still am.
I want to be careful about what I claim from that. A powerful experience is not proof of anything about the universe. Brains under the influence of a strong compound can produce extraordinary states, and those states feel more real than real. That is a known feature of them.
What I can say honestly is that the experience changed how I relate to my own mind. It made the distinction between awareness and content something I had lived rather than read about.
Competing answers
There are serious people on every side of this.
Some argue consciousness is entirely produced by the brain, and that when we understand the brain fully the mystery will dissolve. Others argue that consciousness may be more basic than matter, a property of reality rather than something brains generate. Others think the question itself is confused.
I do not know which is right. My own experiences pull me in a particular direction, and I will write about that direction openly in other pieces. But I would be doing you a disservice if I presented my convictions as established science. They are not.
Test it yourself
You do not need a white room to explore this. Sit quietly for a few minutes. Notice a thought arrive and leave. Then ask: what noticed it?
Do not try to answer in words. Just look.
Whatever is doing the looking is the thing this whole question is about. It has been with you your entire life. Most of us never turn around to see it.
This is the first piece in a series I am calling Explorations of Consciousness. I would love to hear what you find when you look.
