← All writing

Consciousness

Where Science Meets the Mystery of Consciousness

Neuroscience has explained a great deal. The most important part is still a mystery, and saying so is not anti-science.

I am a technologist. I trust evidence. I have spent my career building systems that either work or do not, and I do not have much patience for claims that cannot be checked.

I am also someone who has had experiences I cannot explain. Holding both of those at once has taught me a lot about intellectual humility.

What neuroscience has explained

A great deal. Scientists can map which brain regions are involved in vision, language, memory, emotion, and decision making. They can see how anesthesia changes brain activity. They can study how damage to specific areas changes specific abilities. Research into the neural correlates of consciousness, the brain activity that goes along with particular experiences, has made real progress.

This is genuine knowledge, hard won, and it matters.

What remains unresolved

Correlation is not explanation. Knowing which brain activity accompanies the experience of red does not tell us why that activity is accompanied by experience at all. Philosophers call this the hard problem, and there is no consensus on how to solve it, or whether science as currently practiced can.

There is also no agreed definition of consciousness, no reliable test for it, and several competing theories that make different predictions.

The two mistakes

The first mistake is to claim science has already explained consciousness, and anything left over is mysticism. That overstates what we know.

The second mistake is to treat the gap as permission to believe anything. Not knowing how consciousness arises does not make every spiritual claim true. That overstates what we do not know.

How I try to hold it

When I write about consciousness, I try to separate four things. What I experienced. How I interpret it. What could be tested. And what is actually established. They are not the same, and blurring them does a disservice to readers on every side.

My experiences have shaped my convictions. I will share those convictions openly. But I will try never to present them as findings.

Humility as a strength

The most interesting scientists and contemplatives I have encountered share something. They are comfortable saying "I do not know." That is not weakness. It is what keeps inquiry alive.

Consciousness may be the last great frontier of understanding. It deserves both rigor and wonder, and it is big enough for both.

neuroscienceconsciousnesssciencehumilityExplorations of Consciousness
Jaime Boyaca

Technology executive, speaker and explorer of consciousness. This idea is also the heart of his keynote From Reaction to Response.